Several stories have been written over the past few weeks regarding GM and Chrysler making great strides to restructure their businesses in light of the economic climate. Unfortunately, minorities, who own less than 5 percent of new-car dealerships nationwide, have been severely affected by the market downturn just like majority-owned dealerships.
But somewhere along the way, a sense of history has been lost regarding minorities in the auto industry. It wasn't until early this decade that automakers began to make a concerted effort to allocate a handful of high-line import dealerships, like Audi, BMW, Jaguar, Lexus, Mercedes and Infiniti, to minority dealers. While we spend a fair share of our income flossing around in these brands, we've made small gains in actually having an ownership stake -- where the real money is made. Many of us have been giving domestic automakers a lot of flack during these troubled times, but they have been recognizing the need for minority-owned dealerships since the seventies.
Like Chrysler, GM finally announced late last week that 44 minority dealers were on its hit list and were scheduled to be close within the next 18 months. Unlike Chrysler, GM is being tight-lipped as to the breakout by ethnicity.
While minorities are expected to represent over half of the U. S. population by 2050, according to a number of statistical studies, the majority community has been slow to recognize this. Advocacy groups such as Rainbow/PUSH have been instrumental in making sure that automakers and other groups fairly represent America's diversity.
As a result of a recent blog post BV published about Chrysler's minority dealers crying foul, we decided to reach out to Glenda Gill, who oversees the Rainbow/PUSH office in Los Angeles, where a number of import automakers are based. We wanted to get five reasons from Gill detailing the need for minority-owned dealerships. Here's what she had to say:
1. We are more than just the drive. We can be entrepreneurs as well and should have a mutually beneficial, reciprocal trade relationship.
2. Ethnic minorities represent 22 percent of the auto-buying public and the population continues to rise. We must be represented under America's big tent. How can cars be sold to a market that is for the most part marginalized?
3. It gives minorities the ability to be business owners on an even playing field. Some of us as workers and some even as business owners. We deserve the chance as much as anyone else to have our own business. When we do have the chance at ownership, we employ about 60 percent minorities.
4. We're three times more likely to hire from our own community. We also become the major contributor of philanthropic traditional and nontraditional community causes and organizations, such as a church building fund, little league games and urban literacy projects, that otherwise would not be funded.
5. When there is a downsizing, ethnic communities feel the impact disproportionately -- mostly because we are usually the victims of "last hired, first fired." We also tend to have dealerships in low-traffic locations, are underfunded and have a lack of resources to keep our businesses afloat.
Give us your thoughts. Do you think that in the midst of this economic turmoil minorities should have more of an ownership stake? Or should we subscribe to the philosophy of survival of the fittest?




Comments: (6)
Add a comment
By: babylove on 6/23/2009 12:28PM
At this time it is survival of the fittest. However, The manufactures should work closely with the minority dealership that has the highest sales. High sales mean they have a good reputation, good customer base and good marketing. So, that minority dealership would have a greater chance of returned customers. which will make them reliable and give them staying power.
Chrysler and GM manufactures should not want to lose that customer base. Ultimately it is the Their customers. One thing for sure is good customers do not complain. They just go some where else, like a Honda Dealership. When Chrysler & GM make such a change. They just gave their customers the thought to make a change. Now they will buy that new Honda that they have been considering.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Ron Patton on 6/23/2009 3:11PM
After serving in the USArmy for almost ten years, I joined the union to product my diveristy oppoertunities. After leaving the union and ending up in the retail auto sales industry, it really became clear the racism and lack of diversity in the auto industry. In fact the minorit owner in my local community supposedly had his horses heads lopped off in an attempt to "scare" him. Unfortunately the civilian population does not keep statical data on how many (particularly African-Americans) were forced to either leave the "car business" or file lawsuits primarily over the lack of opportunity to advance. The dealership environment is the second to the last vestige of the "Good Ole Boy" network outside of the banks and many Black finance, sales, closers, continually are bypassed for the "young, good-looking, white guys and particularly in finance and business offices white women. In the 9 years I sold cars I watched time after time senior, skilled Black sales reps get passed over, or fired when they wanted to know when they "could get of the line!"
It reminded me of the military and the abuse of the "buffalo soldiers" then and now who "CARRY"
the United States military world-wide without the proper credit. I outsold, outworked, and out "grossed" (highest commission) per car. I won more trips to Vegas, more prizes, and more "plagues" than the hand-picked, (spoon-fed) white counterparts with no upward mobility offered. The auto industry DID NOT collapse. The banks overcharged in interest, took loans out to 72 or 84 months and pretty much "raped" the minorities so bad that when the internet started teaching folks how to buy a car.....most were furious. The opportunity to achieve repeat business was washed away with the excessive interest charged to minorities. Do yourself a favor before you try to comment/inform on the auto industry talk to ex "car guys" or better yet conduct a survey on the auto industry. Wells Fargo sued for 24% interest charged to minority females, minority customers stuffed into cars merely for profit reasons, dleaerships unable to maintain enough sales reps due to theft of their commissions. The list goes on and on for nine years I witnessed. Do you really think the "powers that be" would ever want minority representation at the highest levels WHILE they are stealing blind everyone NOT in their loop????
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: eric on 6/23/2009 7:02PM
Rainbow/PUSH?...LOL Get real! What have they and Jesse been doing all this time, and before this? This is nothing but another attempt to put Rainbow/PUSH and Jesse Jackson into the limelight! And, let's be honest here, what is Rainbow/Push going to do? They'll just do the same as they've always have done...NOTHING but talk! Next thing they'll be doing is calling for another stupid march that only makes black people look ridiculous!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: joantaylor on 6/25/2009 12:30AM
People of color in America need to have an identity check then the CEOS' of corporate America need to recognize the intelligence, the cotributions that black americans could have for their companies rather than look back on one's past; and believe that people no matter what their cultural, economic, background says about them.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: PjS on 6/28/2009 1:16PM
Minorities should have every opportunity to own new-car dealerships as long as they pay the same licensing/franchise fees, finance charges, taxes and lot fees as every other new-car dealership owner, WITHOUT government assistance funded by taxpayers.
As for Rainbow/PUSH, I'm sure they are up to their usual extortionist and intimidation tactics, threatening to boycott, unless corporate America falls in line and does exactly what they want. I hope it doesn't work and GM, Chrysler, and Ford refuse to cave in.
Intelligent people of all ethnicities will still buy GM, Chrysler, and Ford products as long as they continue to improve the quality and value of their vehicles, as they have been doing over recent years, making them more and more competitive with the various imports.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Lee Putney on 7/14/2009 11:26AM
Next time you visit one of these so called "Minority Dealerships" take a tour into the managment meeting.........No black managers.....very few black sales people..No black mechanics...This is a industry secret, keep this between us....we don't hire us....we are afriad they might THINK we are a black owned business...ssshhhhhhhh....don't tell "massa"(white people) we be the 'ownnass'(owners).....shame - shame - shame......yet as soon as THEY want to close one minority dealership we go to Rianbow/ Push Jesse or Rev Al......who are will fooling?
Reply to this Comment | Report This